@Tkc74 I find the behavior puzzling and have to agree with you that it seems triggered (that is, reactionary and not entirely rational).
Is there too much worry about cheating going on, particularly among less experienced players? Yes, probably.
Is cheating a serious problem in the online chess community in 2019? Yes, absolutely.
Shaming or insulting players who want to discuss the problem of cheating is out of line; even worse is this new trend I seem to be witnessing, where some are claiming that discussing cheating is worse than cheating itself. I have a hard time wrapping my head around that one.
One update to share. In the past hour, I learned that the player I reported has been banned and I was thanked for helping to identify the problem. My reaction isn't one of vindication ("Got him!"), but more along the lines of, "Huh. Interesting. So I was right to be suspicious." I was ready to believe I was mistaken; had nothing happened with this last report of mine, I would have just figured the player had a string of great games, and let it go.
My advice to people on both sides of the issue would be as follows:
(1) If you think cheating IS NOT a problem, fine. Ignore the discussions of cheating by other players and look for conversations where you can actually contribute something other than snark and insults. By no stretch of the imagination do you have a right to insist that others not discuss the topic.
(2) If you think cheating IS a problem, understand that it probably isn't as large a problem as you think. Never openly accuse another player of cheating; instead, do research, make some notes, and if you still think your suspicions are justified, file a report. You may not hear back from the mods; if you don't, you should figure that an investigation with tools you don't have access to found there wasn't an issue and, at this point, you should let it go.
Hope this helps.
Is there too much worry about cheating going on, particularly among less experienced players? Yes, probably.
Is cheating a serious problem in the online chess community in 2019? Yes, absolutely.
Shaming or insulting players who want to discuss the problem of cheating is out of line; even worse is this new trend I seem to be witnessing, where some are claiming that discussing cheating is worse than cheating itself. I have a hard time wrapping my head around that one.
One update to share. In the past hour, I learned that the player I reported has been banned and I was thanked for helping to identify the problem. My reaction isn't one of vindication ("Got him!"), but more along the lines of, "Huh. Interesting. So I was right to be suspicious." I was ready to believe I was mistaken; had nothing happened with this last report of mine, I would have just figured the player had a string of great games, and let it go.
My advice to people on both sides of the issue would be as follows:
(1) If you think cheating IS NOT a problem, fine. Ignore the discussions of cheating by other players and look for conversations where you can actually contribute something other than snark and insults. By no stretch of the imagination do you have a right to insist that others not discuss the topic.
(2) If you think cheating IS a problem, understand that it probably isn't as large a problem as you think. Never openly accuse another player of cheating; instead, do research, make some notes, and if you still think your suspicions are justified, file a report. You may not hear back from the mods; if you don't, you should figure that an investigation with tools you don't have access to found there wasn't an issue and, at this point, you should let it go.
Hope this helps.