lichess.org
Donate

What do you think of the Scandi?

The Qxd5 Scandinavian just seems like white gets an easy edge because of black's wasted tempi. The Nf6 Scandinavian is hardly better if white simply plays d4 and then after Nxd5 plays c4. So in the queen takes line you lose tempi because your queen gets kicked around and if you play Nf6 and then Nxd5 you lose tempi because your knight gets kicked around. It's not rocket science to understand that white gets an edge by just playing natural moves. You can try for the Icelandic Gambit but white can spoil your fun by playing Bb5+ and, again, white gets an edge with natural moves.

A lot of beginners think it's best to play defenses where there are very few lines but usually if lines are easy for black to play they're also easy for white to play. Everybody has to figure out what their personal strengths and weaknesses are by playing lots of games and observing which types of positions seem to work out best for you. Frankly, it's a much better use of time and money to buy books with tactical puzzles. Opening books are only worth buying if you've got an insanely good memory and/or you're at least a class A player or better.

To be blunt, lots of IMs and GMs that can't make a comfortable living playing in chess tournaments try to make money by writing chess opening books or teaching young students. Frankly, I think young people should learn something more worthwhile than chess like music or a foreign language, Chess is a game and games should be fun. Kids that take chess lessons will tend to take it too seriously and get emotionally upset when they lose. I've never taken a chess lesson and I do not own a single chess book and I'm around a 2000 player. You can be a decent player without getting obsessed by the game.
@piscatorox i skimmed through the line you just said. It has similar ideas with the Portuguese where if white doesnt castle immediately and waste moves, he won't be castling anytime soon. I think itll be extremely good for bullet or blitz but idk about classical as instead of Ng5+, Be2 seems to kill all attacks as after Qd4 White can castle next move. I haven't looked at it too much but seems worth the time :D


This game I played at an otb tournament. The ratings are DWZ (Deutsche Wertungszahl), not Elo.
#41
"The Qxd5 Scandinavian just seems like white gets an easy edge because of black's wasted tempi. "
This seems so, but it is not true.
Take a chess board and play the following two simplified sequences.
A) 1 e4 d5 2 exd5 Qxd5 3 Nc3 Qd6 4 d4 c6 5 Ne4 Qc7
B) 1 e4 c6 2 d4 d5 3 Nc3 dxe4 4 Nxe4 Qc7
At first sight in sequence A) black loses 2 tempi has he spends 3 moves instead of 1 to get his queen to c7.
However, both sequences lead to exactly the same position, so no tempo can be lost.
Closer inspection reveals that in sequence A) white loses a tempo with 2 exd5, while in sequence B) black loses a tempo with 3...dxe4

I love the Modern Scandi! Firstly, it's fun. Secondly, the move d5 immediately forces the opponent in your direction; no choice. And even at the highest level black can equalize. That's why I also have started to study the Old Benoni (although the Dutch Defense is my first choice, as it is dynamic and also a response to 1. d4, 1. c4, 1. kc3 and 1. kf3). The modern scandinavian (2. kf6) opens the door to the dynamic Icelandic and the Scandinavian gambit. Lots of fun. And fun is the first requirement to keep yourself motivated -- especially as a relative newbie like myself.
I use the scandi, but not the classical line: rather, I use the portuguese gambit as it is more aggressive.
This are the first moves: 1.e4 d5 2.exd5 nf6 3.d4 bg4!? and then the best moves are 4.be2 4.nf3 and 4.f3! which is the best move and the most aggressive. This variation is very aggressive and give lots of development for blacks
all those nf6 gambits are just plain bad, because if you just decline them you get a comfotrable+= poisition with more space. e.g 1.e4 d5 2.ed5 Nf6 3.d4 Bg4 4. Bb5 Nbd7 5. Be2 B.e2 6.Qe2 N.d5 Nf3/c4 +=

This topic has been archived and can no longer be replied to.