In no way am I here to shame lichess and its staff but my experience is exactly what @etaLaskera discribed. Edit: referring to post #9
Infact, knowing that lichess does not give statistics on detection methods, I decided to try another approach and sent a moderator a pm. I'll past it here. Message sent 4 days ago:
(Self introduction) I just have a question about repors, if it's okay for me to ask, I am wondering if Lichess staff/moderators keep something like a reliability record of users that send in reports of other users. If so, I want to make sure I do the best I can to send in reliable reports. For example, in one of my recent experiences I reported a user with a very offensive username and he was banned the same day.
Now a few days ago I noticed a player that showed all the signs of engine use, I reported him that day, then yesterday he played more perfect games in tournament, I sent them in another report. Today he continues to show signs of engine use, and again sent a report with the games.
Is sending more that one report undesired by the moderators? I want to do my best to only send legitimate reports therefore to not annoy or spam the moderators. If you can clarify this for me I would really appreciate it. I hope to be a reliable report source and not a bothering one.
Thank you in advance. (End of message)
A day or two passed without a reply so I just assumed my message basically fell into the statistics category and I wouldn't get an answer. Or would I ?
Ironicly enough, I was playing in tournament with some of my lichess buddies myself and another saw a user (not the same user as mentioned in the pm) that was clearly using an engine. We both reported him, but to my surprise my initial report was not accepted. Instead a white page appeared and in small black print the was some code a url address and some kind of warning about report accuracy.
100 questions raced through my mind at ones but I quickly went back and sent the report again, this time it went through and within hours the user was blocked.
I'm not sure how to interpret this. The original user I reported plays on with perfect games against stronger players (being only one of many outstanding cases I've recently reported) and I'm left wondering exactly like @etaLaskera. Said.
Anyways try to remember this isn't an attack this is just me posting my experience. I understand moderators are only human to.
Well, their also AI. I mean, um, oh hell idk anymore I need a drink.
Infact, knowing that lichess does not give statistics on detection methods, I decided to try another approach and sent a moderator a pm. I'll past it here. Message sent 4 days ago:
(Self introduction) I just have a question about repors, if it's okay for me to ask, I am wondering if Lichess staff/moderators keep something like a reliability record of users that send in reports of other users. If so, I want to make sure I do the best I can to send in reliable reports. For example, in one of my recent experiences I reported a user with a very offensive username and he was banned the same day.
Now a few days ago I noticed a player that showed all the signs of engine use, I reported him that day, then yesterday he played more perfect games in tournament, I sent them in another report. Today he continues to show signs of engine use, and again sent a report with the games.
Is sending more that one report undesired by the moderators? I want to do my best to only send legitimate reports therefore to not annoy or spam the moderators. If you can clarify this for me I would really appreciate it. I hope to be a reliable report source and not a bothering one.
Thank you in advance. (End of message)
A day or two passed without a reply so I just assumed my message basically fell into the statistics category and I wouldn't get an answer. Or would I ?
Ironicly enough, I was playing in tournament with some of my lichess buddies myself and another saw a user (not the same user as mentioned in the pm) that was clearly using an engine. We both reported him, but to my surprise my initial report was not accepted. Instead a white page appeared and in small black print the was some code a url address and some kind of warning about report accuracy.
100 questions raced through my mind at ones but I quickly went back and sent the report again, this time it went through and within hours the user was blocked.
I'm not sure how to interpret this. The original user I reported plays on with perfect games against stronger players (being only one of many outstanding cases I've recently reported) and I'm left wondering exactly like @etaLaskera. Said.
Anyways try to remember this isn't an attack this is just me posting my experience. I understand moderators are only human to.
Well, their also AI. I mean, um, oh hell idk anymore I need a drink.