I always assumed without giving it much thought, that books and databases were allowed in correspondence games and engines weren't.
However yesterday I wondered if it was allowed to analyse the position with other players.
So I just looked in the "question and answers" section, but I'm more confused than before.
Concerning whether the help of another human player is allowed or not, it seems that the question hasn't been raised. Or at least I didn't see it.
It seems clear that the use of books and database is allowed, however, there are numerous questions about engines and no clear answer. Some say it is allowed, other say that it is not, and other say that it is allowed in the official rules but forbidden on Lichess. But it seems there are no published rules to back any of this up.
Anyway this led me to thinking that the "question and answers" was not a very appropriate tool. There are a lot of similar questions and the answers are contradictory and we don't know who to trust since none of these appear as the official Lichess answer.
My point is that the rules applied on Lichess, for correspondence games or any other form of chess, should be published somewhere, in a very accessible place.
This question for instance shows how confused people can be about that : lichess.org/qa/1922/what-are-the-rules-of-correspondence-chess-system
Also if anyone knows for sure what is the policy regarding human or engine help in correspondence chess, I'm interested.
ps : We can also see the use for published rules, when we see all the people complaining in the forum about losing on time against a player who has just a knight or a bishop.
However yesterday I wondered if it was allowed to analyse the position with other players.
So I just looked in the "question and answers" section, but I'm more confused than before.
Concerning whether the help of another human player is allowed or not, it seems that the question hasn't been raised. Or at least I didn't see it.
It seems clear that the use of books and database is allowed, however, there are numerous questions about engines and no clear answer. Some say it is allowed, other say that it is not, and other say that it is allowed in the official rules but forbidden on Lichess. But it seems there are no published rules to back any of this up.
Anyway this led me to thinking that the "question and answers" was not a very appropriate tool. There are a lot of similar questions and the answers are contradictory and we don't know who to trust since none of these appear as the official Lichess answer.
My point is that the rules applied on Lichess, for correspondence games or any other form of chess, should be published somewhere, in a very accessible place.
This question for instance shows how confused people can be about that : lichess.org/qa/1922/what-are-the-rules-of-correspondence-chess-system
Also if anyone knows for sure what is the policy regarding human or engine help in correspondence chess, I'm interested.
ps : We can also see the use for published rules, when we see all the people complaining in the forum about losing on time against a player who has just a knight or a bishop.